• Welcome!
    Logout|My Dashboard

Court filings: Summer Wind not ‘seaworthy’ - The Galveston County Daily News : Local News

November 27, 2014

Court filings: Summer Wind not ‘seaworthy’

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Related Documents

Posted: Wednesday, May 14, 2014 1:00 am

TEXAS CITY — The barge company involved in a March collision that spilled more than 160,000-gallons of heavy fuel oil into Galveston Bay and the Gulf of Mexico said it should not be held responsible for the spill.

In a federal court filing on Tuesday, Kirby Inland Marine said the ship that collided with its oil-loaded barge was at fault.

On a foggy March 22 morning, the Kirby Inland tugboat Miss Susan was pushing two barges that were loaded with bunker oil. As it was making its way from the Port of Texas City to the Bolivar Peninsula, the cargo ship Summer Wind collided with the lead barge.

The collision happened at the Texas City Y, an area where the Texas City and Houston Ship Channels intersect with the Intracoastal Waterway.

The resulting spill shut down shipping lanes for several days and saw oil wash up on beaches in Galveston and south as far away as Matagorda County.

Tuesday’s filing for exoneration or limitation of liability followed a similar court filing last month in which Kirby Inland claims that the Summer Wind was speeding, did not take evasive action and was not “seaworthy.”

In Tuesday’s filing, Kirby maintains “the resulting loss, damage and injury, if any, was neither caused nor contributed to by any fault or neglect on the part of Kirby Inland Marine … Rather the incident was caused solely by the fault and or neglect of parties and/or vessels for whose actions Kirby Inland Marine LP is not responsible.”

In records obtained by The Daily News, a post-collision inspection of the Summer Wind by the U.S. Coast Guard found issues with the ship’s navigation equipment. Previous inspections of the ship by Greek officials found several violations, records show.

An attorney representing the Summer Wind’s owners did not respond to a late afternoon request for comment.

A Coast Guard investigation into the collision continues. Officials have not said when they expect the investigation to conclude.

For now, Kirby is listed as the “responsible party,” meaning that because the oil leaked from its vessel, the company is responsible for paying for all of the cleanup costs and initial spill claims.

In its court filings on Tuesday, Kirby Inland is asking the court that should it rule against exoneration to limit the company’s liability to $5.15 million.

Sean O’Rourke, an attorney who filed a lawsuit on behalf of several fishing charter companies and bait shops, said Kirby’s filing was expected.

“Kirby is going to do everything in their power to avoid responsibility,” O’Rourke said. “With their filing of this limitation, they have signaled their intent to avoid compensating business and individuals for legitimate damages suffered as a result of this spill.”

A call to Kirby Inland was not returned.

Contact Mainland Editor T.J. Aulds at 409-683-5334 or tjaulds@galvnews.com.